Ben Goldacre

  • 5 Jan 2009
  • Reading time 3 mins
Login to add to reading list

Ben Goldacre, columnist in the Guardian, and author of Bad Science, describes himself as a nerdy scientist and a doctor and tries to create the impression that he is this innocent crusader for the truth. His journalistic approach, however, is much more of spiteful innuendo and vitamin pill hater irrespective of the facts. He twists the truth and likes to get ‘vitamin pill salesman’ and other such derogatory phrases in as often as possible in reference to me. (One rather classic example is his description of my graduating from university in 1979 as ‘leaving college’.) Although his main line of attack usually relates to my referencing or not referencing something in a book, hypocritically he doesn’t give references to support his arguments so no-one can really dig deeper for themselves. One of the hallmarks of proper scientific debate is an open mind to explore hypotheses and examine the evidence. This isn’t his style. In fact, there’s a book on him called Junk Journalism: Ben Goldacre, quackbusters and corporate science’ by investigative reporter Martin Walker, available as a free download, which makes Goldacre’s underhand journalistic tactics and corporate and pharmaceutical interests quite transparent. Well worth a read. How on earth this detailed critique hasn’t made it onto his Wikipedia entry never ceases to amaze me.

Despite claims to the contrary Goldacre isn’t really a scientist in the sense that he hasn’t published a single scientific trial if your search on the net. He’s a commentator and a journalist – award winning at that, but he does fail to admit that his first award was paid by the pharmaceutical giant GlaxoSmith Kline, followed by another, paid by Syngenta, the agrochemical business making GM seeds. Occasionally he does say bad things about drug trials but he’s missed breaking all the big stories – the ineffectiveness of statins, the increased suicide risk of anti-depressants, the proven danger of giving anti-psychotic drugs to young people with depression and old people with memory loss, to name a few. I’ve even fed him information on these but he wasn’t interested.

His Wikipedia entry says he’s a psychiatrist so he should know a ......

The full content of this report is only viewable by 100% Health Club members.

MEMBERS have free access to 100's of Reports, a monthly 100% Health Newsletter, free use of the 100% Health programme with unlimited reassessments and big discounts, up to 30% off books, supplements and             foods at HOLFORDirect.com.

JOIN THE          WITH A FREE
ONE MONTH TRIAL MEMBERSHIP.






Find out more
Top